Egypt might help maintain order in Gaza

[Dreamer128]

The Egyptian news agency MENA reports that President Hosni Mubarak has agreed to a request from Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon to help the Palestinians maintain security in the Gaza Strip after Israeli troops withdraw from the area.

Mr Mubarak reportedly told Prime Minister Sharon that he was prepared to send security experts to the Gaza Strip to restore order and train Palestinian police officers. The Egyptian president said such assistance would be granted "after consultation with the Palestinian Authority".

However since Mr Sharon has been facing opposition from members of his own Likud party, it is still uncertain whether the Israeli cabinet will support the decision to withdraw from Gaza.

(rnw.nl)

[promethius9594]

heh, thats like if bush told the US that he was going to give california back to mexico... of course its not going to be popular with the israeli's... its giving something back that was rightfully taken during a war where palestine was the unjust agressor against israel.

[Timber Loftis]

After Egypt was the main aggressor of concern in 1967, the peace between that country and Israel has been long-standing. It is one country that was able to accept the situation. This may in fact be a good solution. Isn't the situation between Israel and Palestine severe enough that any reasonable alternative should be considered?

[Black Baron]

Considering the fact that Egypt has done nothing to stop the weapon smugglers from his border, i find it's promise untrustworthy.

[promethius9594]

eh, i think they can be trusted, and i'm not against bringing in another country to help. what im saying is that it is understandable that the israelis don't want to give up the gaza. legally its theirs by right and they dont HAVE to give it back. that they even are going to is a charitable act on the part of the israelis... it does make sense that the people don't like it though.

[Black Baron]

They do not stop the smugglers, about what trust do we talk about? If they cared about the palestinians, Mubarak could have long ago stop the smugglers. Than no "rainbow in the sky" and 50 destroyed buildings in tel sultan.

[promethius9594]

they arent particularly biased... we're not talking about smuggling, we're talking about would they go balistic on palestinians or not. the answer is most likely no.

are you forgetting who youre arguing against? i'm the one who believes that israel has a valid claim to the gaza strip and that any willingness to give that back is an act of charity. maybe you have a bigger fish to fry than whether or not egyptions want to kill palestinians?

[Black Baron]

I appreciate your support promethius [img]smile.gif[/img] , i merely point out that the smugglers will continue undisturbed.

[Khazadman Risen]

When the Israelis and Egyptians signed their peace accord, Israel gave back the Sinai. They offered to give back the Gaza strip also, but the Egyptians wanted to have nothing to do with the Palestinians. They knew they were nothing but trouble.

[Timber Loftis]

Israel is party to the UN Treaty, which forbids annexing territory. Promethius (and perhaps Black Baron, no sure) I can see no real argument that Israel has rights to Gaza -- other than those based on conquest, which as I said Israel agreed to eschew.