Eddings or Gemmel?

Lord High Eater of Legs · 02-02-2003, 05:58 AM

Ok, this is just a poll on which book I should buy:

WillowIX · 02-02-2003, 10:20 AM

I am a great fan of David Gemmell. His books are astounding. I have never bothered to read David Eddings since I find his books rather childish. Therefore I may not be the best hudge of which book you should purchase. On the other hand I don´t think Stormrider excels as Gemmell´s other books. It is unfortunately a step down in my opinion, whereas the first book (Ravenheart) is as good as his earlier works. I regret to say Stormrider left me, in some degree, disappointed. Of course, if you have read Ravenheart, there is no reason not to read the sequel.

Edit: The mrs wanted me to tell you that she didn´t write this. Stephen.

[ 02-02-2003, 10:22 AM: Message edited by: WillowIX ]

Legolas · 02-04-2003, 11:05 AM

Can't vote there, as I have only read little from both authors. From what I've seen, Gemmel writes fast-paced, full of action stories but is lacking somewhat in depth, while Eddings' tales are set in a well-developed world, but the storyline is a common one in fantasy worlds, and the telling is slightly on the childish side. However, looking at the books you are considering purchasing, you know you like both authors' works. In which case I would say it doesn't matter which one you buy as the other two will follow soon enough.

Dace De'Briago · 02-04-2003, 07:27 PM

Best books -

Gemmell: Druss the Legend
Eddings: Belgareth the Sorceror

These books are both amazing, and I will read either quite happily. I know it's not quite a decisive 'he is better than him', but at least it's honest.

kev · 02-10-2003, 09:15 AM

I like both authors but I read more Eddings because the books are cheaper & come in a standard paperback size.

Curlcurl · 02-19-2003, 06:26 PM

Eddings for readability, I agree the storyline and telling is childish or uncomplex but the humour is sensational and its a classic all round series

View Poll Results: Eddings or Gemmel?
Belgarath The Sorcerer by David Eddings	6	75.00%
Polgara The Sorceress by David Eddings	2	25.00%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 8. You may not vote on this poll

02-02-2003, 05:58 AM	#1
Lord High Eater of Legs Zhentarim Guard Join Date: November 16, 2002 Location: Surrey, England Age: 36 Posts: 359	Ok, this is just a poll on which book I should buy: __________________ [img]\"http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v299/OhGodtheRats/HeadInjuryGun.jpg\" alt=\" - \" />

02-02-2003, 10:20 AM	#2
WillowIX Apophis Join Date: July 10, 2001 Location: By a big blue lake, Canada Age: 51 Posts: 4,628	I am a great fan of David Gemmell. His books are astounding. I have never bothered to read David Eddings since I find his books rather childish. Therefore I may not be the best hudge of which book you should purchase. On the other hand I don´t think Stormrider excels as Gemmell´s other books. It is unfortunately a step down in my opinion, whereas the first book (Ravenheart) is as good as his earlier works. I regret to say Stormrider left me, in some degree, disappointed. Of course, if you have read Ravenheart, there is no reason not to read the sequel. Edit: The mrs wanted me to tell you that she didn´t write this. Stephen. [ 02-02-2003, 10:22 AM: Message edited by: WillowIX ] __________________ Confuzzled by nature.

02-04-2003, 07:27 PM	#4
Dace De'Briago Silver Dragon Join Date: December 28, 2002 Location: Wales Age: 44 Posts: 1,617	Best books - Gemmell: Druss the Legend Eddings: Belgareth the Sorceror These books are both amazing, and I will read either quite happily. I know it's not quite a decisive 'he is better than him', but at least it's honest. __________________ Warning: Powergamer

02-10-2003, 09:15 AM	#5
kev Drizzt Do'Urden Join Date: April 4, 2002 Location: North Western Australia Age: 60 Posts: 670	I like both authors but I read more Eddings because the books are cheaper & come in a standard paperback size. __________________

02-04-2003, 11:05 AM	#3
Legolas Jack Burton Join Date: March 31, 2001 Location: The zephyr lands beneath the brine. Age: 40 Posts: 5,459	Can't vote there, as I have only read little from both authors. From what I've seen, Gemmel writes fast-paced, full of action stories but is lacking somewhat in depth, while Eddings' tales are set in a well-developed world, but the storyline is a common one in fantasy worlds, and the telling is slightly on the childish side. However, looking at the books you are considering purchasing, you know you like both authors' works. In which case I would say it doesn't matter which one you buy as the other two will follow soon enough.

02-19-2003, 06:26 PM	#6
Curlcurl Elite Waterdeep Guard Join Date: November 27, 2002 Location: Sydney Age: 51 Posts: 49	Eddings for readability, I agree the storyline and telling is childish or uncomplex but the humour is sensational and its a classic all round series

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
David Eddings - a bit special?	shamrock_uk	Entertainment (Movies, TV Shows and Books/Comics)	13	06-09-2009 08:04 AM
a poll.... who loves eddings books???	arion windrider	Entertainment (Movies, TV Shows and Books/Comics)	3	12-22-2002 04:01 AM