A Chill Wind is Blowing

[pritchke]

'A Chill Wind is Blowing in This Nation...'
Transcript of the speech given by actor Tim Robbins to the National Press Club in Washington, D.C., on April 15, 2003.

TIM ROBBINS: Thank you. And thanks for the invitation. I had originally been asked here to talk about the war and our current political situation, but I have instead chosen to hijack this opportunity and talk about baseball and show business. (Laughter.) Just kidding. Sort of.

I can't tell you how moved I have been at the overwhelming support I have received from newspapers throughout the country in these past few days. I hold no illusions that all of these journalists agree with me on my views against the war. While the journalists' outrage at the cancellation of our appearance in Cooperstown is not about my views, it is about my right to express these views. I am extremely grateful that there are those of you out there still with a fierce belief in constitutionally guaranteed rights. We need you, the press, now more than ever. This is a crucial moment for all of us.

For all of the ugliness and tragedy of 9-11, there was a brief period afterward where I held a great hope, in the midst of the tears and shocked faces of New Yorkers, in the midst of the lethal air we breathed as we worked at Ground Zero, in the midst of my children's terror at being so close to this crime against humanity, in the midst of all this, I held on to a glimmer of hope in the naive assumption that something good could come out of it.

I imagined our leaders seizing upon this moment of unity in America, this moment when no one wanted to talk about Democrat versus Republican, white versus black, or any of the other ridiculous divisions that dominate our public discourse. I imagined our leaders going on television telling the citizens that although we all want to be at Ground Zero, we can't, but there is work that is needed to be done all over America. Our help is needed at community centers to tutor children, to teach them to read. Our work is needed at old-age homes to visit the lonely and infirmed; in gutted neighborhoods to rebuild housing and clean up parks, and convert abandoned lots to baseball fields. I imagined leadership that would take this incredible energy, this generosity of spirit and create a new unity in America born out of the chaos and tragedy of 9/11, a new unity that would send a message to terrorists everywhere: If you attack us, we will become stronger, cleaner, better educated, and more unified. You will strengthen our commitment to justice and democracy by your inhumane attacks on us. Like a Phoenix out of the fire, we will be reborn.

And then came the speech: You are either with us or against us. And the bombing began. And the old paradigm was restored as our leader encouraged us to show our patriotism by shopping and by volunteering to join groups that would turn in their neighbor for any suspicious behavior.

In the 19 months since 9-11, we have seen our democracy compromised by fear and hatred. Basic inalienable rights, due process, the sanctity of the home have been quickly compromised in a climate of fear. A unified American public has grown bitterly divided, and a world population that had profound sympathy and support for us has grown contemptuous and distrustful, viewing us as we once viewed the Soviet Union, as a rogue state.

This past weekend, Susan and I and the three kids went to Florida for a family reunion of sorts. Amidst the alcohol and the dancing, sugar-rushing children, there was, of course, talk of the war. And the most frightening thing about the weekend was the amount of times we were thanked for speaking out against the war because that individual speaking thought it unsafe to do so in their own community, in their own life. Keep talking, they said; I haven't been able to open my mouth.

A relative tells me that a history teacher tells his 11-year-old son, my nephew, that Susan Sarandon is endangering the troops by her opposition to the war. Another teacher in a different school asks our niece if we are coming to the school play. They're not welcome here, said the molder of young minds.

Another relative tells me of a school board decision to cancel a civics event that was proposing to have a moment of silence for those who have died in the war because the students were including dead Iraqi civilians in their silent prayer.

A teacher in another nephew's school is fired for wearing a T- shirt with a peace sign on it. And a friend of the family tells of listening to the radio down South as the talk radio host calls for the murder of a prominent anti-war activist. Death threats have appeared on other prominent anti-war activists' doorsteps for their views. Relatives of ours have received threatening e-mails and phone calls. And my 13-year-old boy, who has done nothing to anybody, has recently been embarrassed and humiliated by a sadistic creep who writes -- or, rather, scratches his column with his fingernails in dirt.

Susan and I have been listed as traitors, as supporters of Saddam, and various other epithets by the Aussie gossip rags masquerading as newspapers, and by their fair and balanced electronic media cousins, 19th Century Fox. (Laughter.) Apologies to Gore Vidal. (Applause.)

Two weeks ago, the United Way canceled Susan's appearance at a conference on women's leadership. And both of us last week were told that both we and the First Amendment were not welcome at the Baseball Hall of Fame.

A famous middle-aged rock-and-roller called me last week to thank me for speaking out against the war, only to go on to tell me that he could not speak himself because he fears repercussions from Clear Channel. "They promote our concert appearances," he said. "They own most of the stations that play our music. I can't come out against this war."

And here in Washington, Helen Thomas finds herself banished to the back of the room and uncalled on after asking Ari Fleischer whether our showing prisoners of war at Guantanamo Bay on television violated the Geneva Convention.

A chill wind is blowing in this nation. A message is being sent through the White House and its allies in talk radio and Clear Channel and Cooperstown. If you oppose this administration, there can and will be ramifications.

Every day, the air waves are filled with warnings, veiled and unveiled threats, spewed invective and hatred directed at any voice of dissent. And the public, like so many relatives and friends that I saw this weekend, sit in mute opposition and fear.

I am sick of hearing about Hollywood being against this war. Hollywood's heavy hitters, the real power brokers and cover-of-the- magazine stars, have been largely silent on this issue. But Hollywood, the concept, has always been a popular target.

I remember when the Columbine High School shootings happened. President Clinton criticized Hollywood for contributing to this terrible tragedy -- this, as we were dropping bombs over Kosovo. Could the violent actions of our leaders contribute somewhat to the violent fantasies of our teenagers? Or is it all just Hollywood and rock and roll?

I remember reading at the time that one of the shooters had tried to enlist to fight the real war a week before he acted out his war in real life at Columbine. I talked about this in the press at the time. And curiously, no one accused me of being unpatriotic for criticizing Clinton. In fact, the same radio patriots that call us traitors today engaged in daily personal attacks on their president during the war in Kosovo.

Today, prominent politicians who have decried violence in movies -- the "Blame Hollywooders," if you will -- recently voted to give our current president the power to unleash real violence in our current war. They want us to stop the fictional violence but are okay with the real kind.

And these same people that tolerate the real violence of war don't want to see the result of it on the nightly news. Unlike the rest of the world, our news coverage of this war remains sanitized, without a glimpse of the blood and gore inflicted upon our soldiers or the women and children in Iraq. Violence as a concept, an abstraction -- it's very strange.

As we applaud the hard-edged realism of the opening battle scene of "Saving Private Ryan," we cringe at the thought of seeing the same on the nightly news. We are told it would be pornographic. We want no part of reality in real life. We demand that war be painstakingly realized on the screen, but that war remain imagined and conceptualized in real life.

And in the midst of all this madness, where is the political opposition? Where have all the Democrats gone? Long time passing, long time ago. (Applause.) With apologies to Robert Byrd, I have to say it is pretty embarrassing to live in a country where a five-foot- one comedian has more guts than most politicians. (Applause.) We need leaders, not pragmatists that cower before the spin zones of former entertainment journalists. We need leaders who can understand the Constitution, congressman who don't in a moment of fear abdicate their most important power, the right to declare war to the executive branch. And, please, can we please stop the congressional sing-a- longs? (Laughter.)

In this time when a citizenry applauds the liberation of a country as it lives in fear of its own freedom, when an administration official releases an attack ad questioning the patriotism of a legless Vietnam veteran running for Congress, when people all over the country fear reprisal if they use their right to free speech, it is time to get angry. It is time to get fierce. And it doesn't take much to shift the tide. My 11-year-old nephew, mentioned earlier, a shy kid who never talks in class, stood up to his history teacher who was questioning Susan's patriotism. "That's my aunt you're talking about. Stop it." And the stunned teacher backtracks and began stammering compliments in embarrassment.

Sportswriters across the country reacted with such overwhelming fury at the Hall of Fame that the president of the Hall admitted he made a mistake and Major League Baseball disavowed any connection to the actions of the Hall's president. A bully can be stopped, and so can a mob. It takes one person with the courage and a resolute voice.

The journalists in this country can battle back at those who would rewrite our Constitution in Patriot Act II, or "Patriot, The Sequel," as we would call it in Hollywood. We are counting on you to star in that movie. Journalists can insist that they not be used as publicists by this administration. (Applause.) The next White House correspondent to be called on by Ari Fleischer should defer their question to the back of the room, to the banished journalist du jour. (Applause.) And any instance of intimidation to free speech should be battled against. Any acquiescence or intimidation at this point will only lead to more intimidation. You have, whether you like it or not, an awesome responsibility and an awesome power: the fate of discourse, the health of this republic is in your hands, whether you write on the left or the right. This is your time, and the destiny you have chosen.

We lay the continuance of our democracy on your desks, and count on your pens to be mightier. Millions are watching and waiting in mute frustration and hope - hoping for someone to defend the spirit and letter of our Constitution, and to defy the intimidation that is visited upon us daily in the name of national security and warped notions of patriotism.

Our ability to disagree, and our inherent right to question our leaders and criticize their actions define who we are. To allow those rights to be taken away out of fear, to punish people for their beliefs, to limit access in the news media to differing opinions is to acknowledge our democracy's defeat. These are challenging times. There is a wave of hate that seeks to divide us -- right and left, pro-war and anti-war. In the name of my 11-year-old nephew, and all the other unreported victims of this hostile and unproductive environment of fear, let us try to find our common ground as a nation. Let us celebrate this grand and glorious experiment that has survived for 227 years. To do so we must honor and fight vigilantly for the things that unite us -- like freedom, the First Amendment and, yes, baseball. (Applause.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

I know, I know another actor whose voice isn't worth anything, but he does bring up some great points on what is happening to and in the US. It so happens that I agree with him.... except for his love of baseball. Way to go for speaking out against the Bush regime.

It's nice to know there is a Canadian who cares.

[Thoran]

or to paraphrase for those with sock drawers to rearrange...

'A Chill Wind is Blowing in This Nation...' Transcript of the speech given by actor Tim Robbins... a few interesting concepts quickly degenerating into rant rant rant, whine whine whine, some more rant, some "sky is falling" hysterics, some blah blah, the end.

In the analysis, his whole argument rests on the assumption that he doesn't have the freedom to communicate his argument...

can you see the fundamental problem with this?

[ 04-17-2003, 03:13 PM: Message edited by: Thoran ]

[Rokenn]

Originally posted by Thoran: or to paraphrase for those with sock drawers to rearrange... Quote: 'A Chill Wind is Blowing in This Nation...' Transcript of the speech given by actor Tim Robbins... a few interesting concepts quickly degenerating into rant rant rant, whine whine whine, some more rant, some "sky is falling" hysterics, some blah blah, the end.

In the analysis, his whole argument rests on the assumption that he doesn't have the freedom to communicate his argument...

can you see the fundamental problem with this? [/QUOTE]Maybe you missed the parts about people getting death threats? That would certainly have a chilling effect free speech imo.

[pritchke]

Of course I care Lil Lil it has nothing to do with borders or nationality however. I care about what will happen to the Iraqi people and those losing family members from both sides, I care about people having to fear about speaking out because of the consequences dealt to them by other people. I care about every single child that has to go to bed hungry at night because there isn't enough food. I care about people having their homes destroyed by people who may not replace them after their work is done. Yes, I do care.

[Thoran]

Yes... death threats. I didn't miss that part and if it's not fabricated I expect that the police will be looking into it (because it's a crime).

All the things he wrote about hostile reaction against war opponents is pretty much the opposite of what I've personally seen, so to be honest I don't believe it. Sure lots of people will argue with war opponents... but that's their right. I have not seen documented evidence of the extreme sorts of activities he's detailing. In reality I've seen a fairly open and honest debate of the issues, democracy in action. Of course when things don't go their way Liberals quickly pull out the "we're being victimized" routine. I think they tend to see themselves as selfless and unthanked martyrs, sacrificing themselves so that we all may see and believe their oh so correct point of view.

There have been anti-war demonstrations ALL OVER the place, and the only violence I can recall was commited by anti-war Canadians against a bunch of young US hockey players.

Do you know of any confirmed attacks of demonstrators or war opponents? I'm not saying it can't happen (there's wacko's out there on both sides of the equation) but I have yet to see it.

[ 04-17-2003, 03:32 PM: Message edited by: Thoran ]

[Rokenn]

This thread: http://www.ironworksforum.com/ubb/no...=000614#000000

Contains two examples. I can find you many more.

Originally posted by pritchke: Of course I care Lil Lil it has nothing to do with borders or nationality however. I care about what will happen to the Iraqi people and those losing family members from both sides, I care about people having to fear about speaking out because of the consequences dealt to them by other people. I care about every single child that has to go to bed hungry at night because there isn't enough food. I care about people having their homes destroyed by people who may not replace them after their work is done. Yes, I do care.

I know you do, and I do too but until our Constitution is rewritten, until speaking becomes outlawed, I am not going to assume the worst of our government and the people who run it...I can expect the worst from them, but I will neither assume nor anticipate it...that's a waste of time and energy that can be best spent doing more worthwhile things...like feeding a hungry person or helping someone repair their home for nothing...there are lots of things we can do as the human race to help make it better for others without giving people who are feeling sorry for themselves because they were uninvited to a party room to make it appear worse than it is and letting them spreading fear and hatred...especially when that's what they are saying of the other side.

[Rokenn]

Here is one a bit more on the humerous side:
http://www.ironworksforum.com/ubb/cg...;f=14;t=000595

[Thoran]

Originally posted by Rokenn: This thread: http://www.ironworksforum.com/ubb/no...=000614#000000 Contains two examples. I can find you many more.

That same thread contains examples on the other side also. As I said above you'll always get the fringe groups, people willing to use violence to emphasize their position. This however is a far cry from government sponsored censorship and one side persecution of the anti-war activists... which does not appear to be happening.

[ 04-17-2003, 03:47 PM: Message edited by: Thoran ]