Nalia, Keldron, or Amoen?

[Vanyel]

I was wondering which of these I should take with my "good" party. My rep is 18 ( or I would take Krogen or Edwin ) My party stands at:
( don't mind my bad spellings plz )

Rastalin - Undead Hunter
Jehira
Minsc
Areia
Amoen/Nalia/Keldorn
Yoshimo/Imoen

I was looking to maybe balence it out a bit. I know that Amoen is a Badass after becoming a Knight, Keldron rocks, and Nalia is a half-mage. So which should I take?

------------------
Hey Big Bird!!
It's time for the counter game!!

Count The Shells,
Suck-A-Duck!

~General of the Dark Overlord's Army of Darkness~

[trux]

w/ Aerie and Jaheira you have a pretty good amount of clerical power. If you have Yoshimo and not Imoen the only area I see which you would need more power in is magic (Aerie can't single-handedly supply all the wizard power,) so Nalia would be pretty good. You have yourself and Minsc (and Jaheira to a certain extent) for your frontline fighters so Keldorn may be a bit overkill in that area.

------------------
a bunch of long hairs.
trux

[Ace Flashheart]

You don't need another Paladin so forget Keldorn, with Nalia, Imoen and Aerie your party will have a heavy bias on magic. My advice is to keep Yoshimo until you get Imoen (no-one say a word) and go with Anomen as he not only is a good fighter but also can boost your healing Magics (Jaheira and Aerie are not wonderfull Clerics), at the very least you can use his priest magic for offensive perposes and the others for defensive.

[debiler]

Originally posted by trux: w/ Aerie and Jaheira you have a pretty good amount of clerical power. If you have Yoshimo and not Imoen the only area I see which you would need more power in is magic (Aerie can't single-handedly supply all the wizard power,) so Nalia would be pretty good. You have yourself and Minsc (and Jaheira to a certain extent) for your frontline fighters so Keldorn may be a bit overkill in that area.

Nalia is NEVER(!) good! See my Nalia hate thread(couple weeks ago)



------------------
EEEEEEEVILL!!!

[trux]

Originally posted by debiler: Nalia is NEVER(!) good! See my Nalia hate thread(couple weeks ago)

I'm certainly no Nalia fan myself (like her better in ToB, though,) but I will NEVER allow Anomen into my party, and in Vanyel's case he has plenty of clerical and figher power but very little magic power - in which case Nalia is the only one out of his choices to choose.

------------------
a bunch of long hairs.
trux

[debiler]

Originally posted by trux: I'm certainly no Nalia fan myself (like her better in ToB, though,) but I will NEVER allow Anomen into my party, and in Vanyel's case he has plenty of clerical and figher power but very little magic power - in which case Nalia is the only one out of his choices to choose.

What about Jan?


------------------
EEEEEEEVILL!!!

[trux]

Originally posted by debiler: What about Jan?

I would certainly pick Jan over Nalia, but Vanyel's question asked to consider from three options: Anomen, Nalia or Keldorn.

If it were my party Jan would be in there way before Nalia (actually, Edwin would be in there before any of them.)

------------------
a bunch of long hairs.
trux

[Jerome]

Erk! I hat Imoen as a party member, childish innocence only gets her so far before you realise she cant cast spells to save herself. Dont get Imoen, get Jan. And Anomen does rock after becomming a kinght... and no more whinging!

Nalia is probably the best Mage a Good party is going to come across...though if you were willing to lower your party's rep to 12 or so Edwin could be brought in.....and we know how good Edwin is..

------------------

Yoshi's good........ *covers mouth and mumbiling something*

------------------

All your base are belong to us! How Are you gentlemen?

Fish?
***********************
Welcome to your doom!!!
***********************

[debiler]

If he weren´t evil, I´d always look to get him in my party before I got anyone else. But the only evil party I played until now sucked after 2-3 hours.

------------------
proud male