Go with Baldur's Gate II. I liked Icewindale just as much as anyone else. But the game didn't have as good a story as Baldur's Gate II. The player character voices were better in Icewindale, but still your characters never said as much as they did in BGII. The weapon styles, and new character kits really added a lot to AD&D. And don't forget about Throne Of Bhaal!
------------------
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, I just don't have to listen.
