05-09-2004, 03:44 PM
|
#57
|
Very Mad Bird 
Join Date: January 7, 2001
Location: Breukelen (over the river from New Amsterdam)
Age: 53
Posts: 9,246
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Jerr Conner:
I'd say what defines a human is when brain activity begins.
|
And what about humans with no brain activity? Do they become another species?
Of course not.
Tell me, if a zygot is not classified under "human" what is it classified under? Fish? Larvae are still insects, they are just in the larvae PHASE. a zygot is a human in it's larva phase. Given TIME and CIRCUMSTANCE it will grow into a human just like any other. Whether it dies in the womb, at age 5 at age 25, at age 75 or 115 it remains human, defined by it's POTENTIAL, not by it's actuality, it's appearance, or it's bodily functions.
Quote:
Of course I don't know when that is.
|
Which is why your definition is erroneous. There is no clear line of yes/no. Too much grey. With mine it is clear. No confusion. Life starts = human. No "six week" confusion. No brain activity confusion. You know because you set a clear and determined boundary.
Quote:
If it were as simple as "inside" of someone, then many men would be guilty of abortion through ejaculation.
|
No. The egg being fertilised so it starts to grow is the initial onset of human life. Sperm is seed. Sperm will not become a human on it. Sperm fertilises an egg. It is the egg that becomes human at the point of fertilisation.
Quote:
On a final note, the Soul need not be a Religious Discussion; it can be a Philosophical Discussion.
|
Most of my religious discussion are philisophical.
|
|
|