Quote:
|
But Azred ... do we live in a democracy ? "Democracy" means "the power to the people".
|
Well, I can't really speak for the everyone else, but America is not a Democracy. The electoral college means that it is technicaly possible for a canidate that no one voted for to become president[1] (This would probably be the end of the electoral college). There are examples where the canidate that people voted for didn't get electoral vote. Good examples of this include the 1876 presidental election in South Carolina, Louisiana, and Flordia (and possibly Oregon depending on who you ask), this was not an issue of faithless electors, but rather was due to the republican lead state governments refusing to accept thousands of (democratic) votes, and then certifying fraudulant results. Another example is the election of 1836 in Virginia where the states electors refused to vote for VP canidate Richard Johnson after alligations that he had lived with a black woman.
A full list of faithless electors is avaible at
http://www.fairvote.org/e_college/faithless.htm
[1] This is tecnhicaly illegal in some (24) states, but usually the punishments are pathetic. For example, in Oklahoma, electors must take an oath to vote for the candidate to whom they are pledged. Violators can be found guilty of a misdemeanor and be subject to a fine of up to $1,000. A fine that small isn't going to stop someone who has decided to screw up the election.
Quote:
|
Politics is NOT supposed, in a democracy, to be a job that only specifically skilled and knowleadgeable people are supposed to perform
|
This is exactly how the electoral college is supposed to work. The electors are supposed to be competent, and therefor are able to overrule a poor decision by the voters. For example, in 1912, James S. Sherman died three days before the election, but still managed to win electoral votes, electing a dead man is what I would call a "poor decision", another example of this is Horace Greeley who was alive for the election, but died before the electoral votes were cast.