OOC:
1. I checked if I could reuse my arrow (checked the cleric's body)
2. I'm not one of those greedy adventurers who kill people for two goldpieces
3. We're too busy listening to the Halfling and tending wounds
4. We've got the mage
5. the bodies aren't going anywhere, and it's too dark to find anything anyway.
Okay, okay. We just plain forgot

But I could have stuck to my former statements