The NVIDIA is a good card and they are usually fair quality. ATI makes excellent cards, but sometimes aren't worth the extra cost. If your warranty on your parts is around 3 yrs I would go ahead and get the NVIDIA, however, if not then get the ATI.
Put it this way. If I was going to get the NVIDIA with a 3 yr warranty I would take the money I saved and buy more RAM. More RAM will affect your video speed just as much if not more as your video card.
------------------
The sexiest elf mage in the land
I feel the need, the need for SPEED!
Peace and Hair grease.
'Deagurth' Artist: Roberto Raba