Hi Thorin,
a fellow German, on this board, welcome !
(even if you are from Düsseldorf, but what the heck, this is a tolerant
board.
)
Unfortunately, ontopic, I cannot help you as I have never played an evil party myself, but I cannot imagine that it is supposed to happen the way you described it.
Happy gaming and posting !
------------------
So long !
R³ - Co-president(s) of the Club of Broken Hearts