Heh.. I think you all should get off the back of Luvian. I do agree with him and I like a person who goes straight to the point and doesn't speak "round" words.
Regarding the "test" - the point there is not whether you kill the genie or not. The point there is whether you want to keep the sword or will give it away. Pretty easy: give away = good, keep = bad, greedy. You chose the last one, now live with the concequences. It's as easy as that. There is no "why this and that" later, you knew the result, you made the choice, now live with it. Use SK and change the alignment if you wish. Doesn't change the fact that you would thwack someone else lateron, just to keep some other "good item".
__________________
|