The Valygar vs Minsc decision really comes down to how do you want to play that character in that slot.
If you want a backstabbing scout, Valygar's your man.
If you just want a solid, traditional tank, then you should lean towards Minsc (and Boo!!). Sarevok is definitely a more dangerous and tougher tank than Minsc, but then you'd miss out on all that Minsc humor.
|