[Lymond]

mad=dog,

I'm pretty sure my character is lawful evil. It's whichever one means that you follow the rules as long as they suit you, or something like that. I took it to mean that you're not a bad guy, but decide for yourself what rules to follow, primarily looking out for yourself.

So here I am about to apprehend a guy I've been hired to capture. We talk, and he comes out with this sphere story. By attempting this quest, it must mean that I believe the guy, in which case why would I kill him? Reading about Valygar, I've learned that killing him is an option, but from a roleplaying standpoint it doesn't make sense to me. It makes even less sense for a Paladin- "Thank you for enlightening me good citizen! No, no need to join my party- I'll just kill you instead."