I prefer the original Diablo, it had more of that "What's around the next corner?" atmosphere than Diablo 2 which was more outside, also, Diablo 1's dungeon was more random that Diablo 2's, many of which aren't random, I also liked Diablo 1's music better.
------------------
Worshipper of Tiax.
Wielder of the ancient Lawyer spells.
Member of the HADB clan.

Ally of the Fluffy Queen and the Dreaded Red Fluffy
General of the highest class and Leader of the Legal Department in the IW Peacekeeping Force.
ORT member, Official Demander of Stuff.
"If Silence is golden, why does everyone talk so much?"