Hmm? Who should join my party?

I'm mage/thief, Korgan, Armon and Edwin when he's available + a special NPC in ToB.

Mage/Thief - I assume multiclassed
Anomen, Fighter->Cleric
Korgan, Berserker
Edwin, Conjurer
ToB NPC

You have, in SoA, 2 tanks already and an excellent Mage. Valgar is a tank type, but that would mean an eventual overkill of tanks( you know what I mean). So I vote for Viconia, for more background spellcasting, because Anomen is better suited to memorising Combat Spells, while Viconia can memorise Party Spells.

IMHO Valgyar is a rather weak tank, while Viconia is a kickass cleric. So I'd definitely go for Viccy. An extra Finger of death or sunray canalways come in handy.

Thanks. Well Viccy since you are on fire I'll go for you. Ha ha. The mob is about to burn her.

Not really related, but in BG1 I always took Viconia in my party, even in good Game. I usually gave her the Helm of Opposite Aligment when my reputation got to 18+, to make sure she don't leave.

Sadly, in BGII there is too much Good aligned characters, so I can't take her in Good game.

But if you I am playing a Evil or Neutral game I take her.

Even less related... am I the only one who enjoyed BG1 more than BG2?

I haven't played BG1 so I don't know.

Even less related... My best friend live in Denmark. I think Denmark people are very cool.