I cant give the pie to rethpian nor am I able to give the potion to toad. Help! How do I do this? I click on use/give and the pie shows but when I click on give I end up giving money, sword or other items to him.

This happened to me . . . first click "give" and then wait a second (mine seemed to default to gold, hm) not go to the top or bottom of the scroll and scroll thru until that tasty pie comes back up. Then give it to him. Hope this helps.

Select give, scroll down to pie, THEN CLICK ON THE TARGET PERSON YOU ARE GIVING TOO. Hope this helps .

Also, Medawa was hyperactive toad. Try clearing out that person's inventory (giver) and tranfer your money so you don't mess up. Leave just the potion. It was really hard to give it to him. Almost had frog legs for dinner.