Help again. I can't seem to figure out how to give the toad potion to Shinwiki. I have it in the "use/give" box, but can't get rid of it.

Also, how do I learn the Identify skill?

Thanks,

Eddie G

Once you've clicked on USE/GIVE check the parchment scroll on bottom left - if it has a blue Use rather than Give highlighted you will have to click on Give to change to Give mode.
(And then you may have to scroll back down to the potion).
Once you have the potion with a blue Give, just Ctrl-click the toad.
Identify - Temple, Priest guild, Training you need Ancient Lore.

PS: It is Mekgawa, the toad by Nymph Lake you give it to, not Shinwiki, the Shaman at the village.