Well Since i played BG1 first I voted for it. It pulled me back alot more then BG2 did. I liked all the outdoor areas.

I liked BG2 and ToB more than anything else.

P.S. BTW, what's up with that banned smartass guy anyway?

BG II and TOB all the way!

BG2's plot was all over the place, imo. Planescape had a more coherent and sophisticated background to drive the story forward. I also thought Planescape presented some interesting moral and ethical dilemmas designed for a more mature audience.

[ 11-13-2002, 12:37 AM: Message edited by: Heartless Butterscotch ]

Fallout 2 and Planescape too.

Among the 4 listed I voted IWD 2 because I like 3rd ed rules are far more than 2nd ed.

The Black Isle rpg i like the most so far is icewind dale2. But a game not on the list that is my all time favorite right now would have to be fallout1 i played it three times in a row right after i beat it i started a new game with a different kind of char i love that game.

Planescape: Torment, of course... Pity it wasn't included in the list. Oh well. ;)

I have BG:II and IWD, and IWD is so repeitive. So iw went for BG:II

Baldur's Gate 2.

I liked the outdoors adventuring in BG1, but they did improve a lot of things in BG2/ToB. BG2 gets my vote.

I haven't played Planescape yet, I hope to be able to soon.