![]() |
I wish my e-mail was big enough to hold it but unfortunatly its not :( mabe you could get /)eath to host it for you so we could all listen to it :D
|
Quote:
|
If you send me the file, I'd be happy to host it for a bit so that everyone can download from one location instead of you having to email everyone. [img]smile.gif[/img]
|
Thanks mate, gonna enjoy this to my morning coffee! :D
|
ME ME ME ME ME ME ME ME!!!!!!!! :D :D :D :D
I will send you the addy! Make it quick!!! I am just so sick and tired of listening to your oldies (joke) :D |
Hey guys. I'm short of time today, but I'll follow this up tonight. I sent a few out yesterday, but the hosting idea is pretty cool. [img]smile.gif[/img]
|
Hugh! LOVE THEM! I listened to them last night! As usual, I'm impressed! :D
|
OK - since you said you'd like some feedback...
Since you're the guy who's always advocating that friends should be able to be honest with each other and criticise each other, I am convinced you won't hold the following against me ;) Let me start out by saying that I think you are an incredibly gifted singer - the two CDs that Moiraine was kind enough to send me are played often! :D You have an amazing range, not only in the music-technical sense, but also in that you can do so many different styles and hit so many different emotions and tones with your voice. That said, I must say that I was less impressed with the three new songs than with some of the older things you did. It may be me, but the production sounds a bit flat to me, I think I'd have liked the sound better if it had some more depth. It seems a bit overproduced, bland. Especially the drums. Of course, I realise that this may be genre-bound, sort of a 'light music' production. But it was somethin I didn't really like. Also, though this is a matter of taste, the songs an sich are not really my style. I think you have done so much more original/interesting stuff before - this sounds more standard to me. Your taste has probably changed, and maybe you prefer to make music that's very easy to the ears, very light. To me it sounds a bit too standard though... all the choirs... you have such an amazing voice, I don't think it needs all the back-up. ;) Some things that I did love: first of all, your singing, of course. It's impeccable. I think it's above dispute that you're a very good singer! What I liked especially was that your voice seems to have a little more 'edge' than I heard before. I also loved the last part of Love Train - it started out a bit timid, but then it bloomed open, got groovy, and your voice really comes loose - some GREAT vocal lines there, I loved it!!! The extended 'hold on's and then the catchy part.. I really liked that. One more thing - the last song (Steal A Heart) is very similar to some of the songs I got from Moiraine... also, that sound effect in that song has been used to death by a few bands, I think, LOL! Anyway, that's my honest opinion - like I was discussing with another IW member the other day, empty praise is so meaningless, and it's no help at all, either. I think honest criticism is kinder than flattery that you don't mean a word of. So I hope you'll not mind [img]smile.gif[/img] I love your voice, but the songs just couldn't really capture me. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm off to listen to Treehouse! :D Oh incidentally, Hugh, what was the band called again that you used to be in? Vertigo or am I mistaken? |
Quote:
In light of what you wrote I should probably clear some things up though. Namely that my co-writer Will is doing a lot of lead vocal on Love Train - including the long hold ons. I'm doing the vox in the big guitar section (the catchy part?), and we're both doing the chanted backing vocals. However I did play everything and arranged it all. I'm not sure if you picked up that the songs were each written/recorded in a day. So as far as production goes I haven't spent much time on it. Ironic that you cited overproduction ;) And the 'choir' is just me, :D although the co-writer of the first song sings a harmony line. Apart from her and the aforementioned Will, I did the lot from scratch on my laptop in a few hour per song, so I'm not too fazed by production criticisms. Especially knowing your genre tastes... ;) (I watched the lost highway back to back with Mullholland Drive the other night BTW) The feedback is good in terms of developing direction, as I'm writing with some new co-writers. I do like what's going on, but I'm sure the songs will develop as time goes on. [ 04-27-2002, 03:12 AM: Message edited by: Yorick ] |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But it's amazing that you can do so much on a laptop....wow!! Quote:
OK, I see your point about production... it seems flat, as if it has only one layer, but that's probably due to time being limited and recording on your laptop. I still think some of the song structures are far less original than earlier things you did though, but oh well ;) Good luck with it, Hugh! [img]smile.gif[/img] And I hope you'll keep us all updated when you have time ;) |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:14 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©2024 Ironworks Gaming & ©2024 The Great Escape Studios TM - All Rights Reserved